Nutrition: Difference between revisions

From the change wiki
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 26: Line 26:


===The ''total'' amount of calories===
===The ''total'' amount of calories===
{{empty}}
Protein and essential fats, ''on their own'', are only a small percent of the calories you need. {{talk|TODO: show maths}} The rest of the calories must be a mix of fats and carbs. The exact ratio doesn't matter as much as some people think - see below.
{{talk|because protein and essential fats, on their own, are only a small fraction of the calories you need. the rest of the calories must be some sort of mix of fats and carbs. the exact ratio doesn't matter as much as some people say - see below}}




Line 38: Line 37:
===Carbs===
===Carbs===
----
----
<small style="background:#F003;border:1px solid #DDD;position:relative;top:-0.5em"> &#x26A0; '''Note:''' If have diabetes: This part does NOT apply to you. You need to be very careful with carbs. But for other people, this holds true:</small>
<small style="background:#F003;border:1px solid #DDD;position:relative;top:-0.5em"> &#x26A0; '''Exception:''' For people with diabetes, carbs '''do''' matter - be careful. But the following applies to everyone else:</small>


Contrary to popular belief, it doesn't matter whether most of your calories come from carbs or fats. It's the overall amount of calories that matter.
Contrary to popular belief,
{{talk|TODO: explain why so many people think it matters: correlations found in studies, which can actually be explained by vitamins and minerals}}
it doesn't matter whether most of your calories come from carbs or fats. The overall amount of calories are what's important.


===="Bad carbs" (i.e. sugar) vs "good carbs"====
===="Bad carbs" (i.e. sugar) vs "good carbs"====
Line 66: Line 67:
====Natural vs artificial flavors====
====Natural vs artificial flavors====
{{empty}}
{{empty}}
{{talk|but there are some minor benefits to natural ''colors'', which i think should be used more often (especially beetroot)}}
{{talk|~ but there are some minor benefits to natural ''colors'', which i think should be used more often (especially beetroot)
{{pbr}}~ also talk about why some flavors ''have to'' be artificial, from a sustainability perspective}}
====Preservatives & additives====
====Preservatives & additives====
{{empty}}
{{empty}}
Line 75: Line 77:
----
----
{{empty}}
{{empty}}
{{talk|the body doesnt care whether it gets its nutrients as long as it gets them. digestibility doesnt have to be an issue: there are ways. phytic acid not as significant as u think. optimal nutrition diet is possible no matter if vegan or not. shitty nutrition is also possible either way. but when it comes to ethics, plant-based is better (another controversial topic with lots of misconceptions - here's a page that clears things up).}}
{{talk|the body doesnt care whether it gets its nutrients as long as it gets them. digestibility doesnt have to be an issue: there are ways. phytic acid not as significant as u think. optimal nutrition diet is possible no matter if veg or non-veg. shitty nutrition is also possible either way.}}
====But ethically, it ''does'' matter.====
====But ethically, it ''does'' matter.====
{{empty}}
{{empty}}
{{talk|TODO: Add: "When it comes to ethics, plant-based is better (another controversial topic with lots of misconceptions - here's a page that clears things up).", after I make the page to link to.}}





Revision as of 07:04, 12 December 2024

This page is going to ruffle a few feathers. There are so many misconceptions about nutrition out there - try to put all that aside when reading this page - try to rebuild an understanding from scratch.

Things that matter

Vitamins & minerals

This section has not been filled in yet.

Protein

This section has not been filled in yet.

Essential fats

This section has not been filled in yet.

The total amount of calories

Protein and essential fats, on their own, are only a small percent of the calories you need. The rest of the calories must be a mix of fats and carbs. The exact ratio doesn't matter as much as some people think - see below.


Things that don't matter


This section is going to cause a lot of controversy, but it needs to be said. Again, try to put any pre-conceived ideas aside, and read the whole page before jumping to conclusions.

Carbs


Exception: For people with diabetes, carbs do matter - be careful. But the following applies to everyone else:

Contrary to popular belief, it doesn't matter whether most of your calories come from carbs or fats. The overall amount of calories are what's important.

"Bad carbs" (i.e. sugar) vs "good carbs"

This section has not been filled in yet.


Fats


Saturated fat and cholesterol

Not harmful. Not essential either.

Seed oils

Not harmful.


Chemicals


Natural vs artificial flavors

This section has not been filled in yet.

Preservatives & additives

This section has not been filled in yet.


Animal-based vs plant-based


This section has not been filled in yet.

But ethically, it does matter.

This section has not been filled in yet.


Honorable mentions

Antioxidants

Flavonoids etc. These help prevent cancer to some extent, but not as significantly as the more essential antioxidants Vitamin C and Vitamin E.

Fiber

This section has not been filled in yet.


FAQ

"WHAT??? You mean junk food is fine??? What about heart disease, type 2 diabetes, cancer, and obesity???"

Obviously there are countless cases of people who get these health problems from an unhealthy diet full of junk food.

But almost every case can be explained by either an excess of calories or a lack of one or more essential nutrients (listed above in "things that matter"). Any studies that control for these factors will say the same thing.

That might sound pedantic, but it actually matters a lot:

Low-quality foods can be part of a healthy diet. People need to know this so they can eat well without spending their whole paycheck on food.