Archive:000/Appliances

From the change wiki
Revision as of 17:25, 23 June 2022 by Elie (talk | contribs) (Created page with "It's a common ''green initiative'' to replace '''old''' appliances with '''new''' ones that use less energy. But in what cases is this actually beneficial to the environment - and in what cases is it '''worse'''? We have to compare the environmental footprint of making a new appliance vs the energy saved. Reasons we shouldn't assume (by default) that replacement is the better choice: * Globally, Energy#Energy_demand|manufacturing uses far more energy than house...")
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

It's a common green initiative to replace old appliances with new ones that use less energy.

But in what cases is this actually beneficial to the environment - and in what cases is it worse?

We have to compare the environmental footprint of making a new appliance vs the energy saved.


Reasons we shouldn't assume (by default) that replacement is the better choice:

  • Globally, manufacturing uses far more energy than household electricity does.
  • Appliance replacement programs are often heavily subsidized. If they don't pay for themselves money-wise, do they pay for themselves energy-wise?
  • If appliances are manufactured in other countries, the environmental impact may be overlooked.
  • In some cases, household electricity is from a more renewable source than what factories use.

Research needed

Things to consider

  • Energy to manufacture a new appliance
    • And all the materials that go into it
  • Energy to dispose of the old one
    • Or maybe that's less of an issue, since the old one will have to be disposed of eventually anyway
      • In that case, consider the energy to eventually dispose of the new appliance
  • Lifespan of the new appliance
  • Remaining lifespan of the old appliance
  • Energy consumed by the new appliance vs the old one (calculate the difference)

What about when the old appliance is almost at its end of life anyway?